Mum accidentally films deadly 'shark attack' while playing with daughter

Marlene Luviano was playing with her toddler when they heard a commotion in the sea.

A young mum has inadvertently filmed a deadly ‘shark attack’ that killed an elderly Canadian tourist.

Joseph 'Jeff' Bynens, 76, was swimming in the sea when he was attacked by the predator on December 14. His female partner was also attacked by the same animal and is currently being treated in hospital. According to reports, Bynens was rescued from the water with most of his leg missing and died of excessive blood loss on the beach in Ixtapa Zihuatanejo, Mexico.

Video grab (Image cropped and swimmer circled) of Marlene Luviano with her daughter as the tourist is supposedly attacked by a shark.
Marlene Luviano was filming her playing with her toddler because it was her birthday when the supposed shark attack occurred. Source: Jam Press

Initial reports said the tourist was killed by a shark, but his injuries led the authorities to suspect that it may have been a crocodile.

Mum inadvertently captures attack

A young mum playing on the beach with her daughter apparently captured the victim’s final moments, possibly shedding light on what animal attacked Bynens.

Marlene Luviano said she asked her partner to film her playing with their toddler daughter because it was her birthday. “We were enjoying the morning on the beach and that’s when we heard something in the sea,” she explained.

Bynens holding onto the buoy and waving his arms in the air for help.
Bynens was filmed swimming to a buoy and waving his arm in the air for help before being dragged under the waves. Source: Jam Press

The clip shows the pair playing on the shoreline before Luviano realises something is not right and leads her daughter away from the shore. She then asks her partner to stop filming.

In the background, Bynens is seen swimming to a buoy and waving his arm in the air for help before being dragged under the waves, presumably by the marine predator. By the time the victim was rescued from the sea, he had already “bled to death”, according to Luviano.

“When they dragged him out of the sea, the wound was already very visible,” she said. “I noticed there was no longer any blood coming out.” The authorities are still investigating whether the Canadian tourist was killed by a shark or a crocodile.

Joseph 'Jeff' Bynens who was killed in the attack. Right is the mum with her toddler telling her dad to stop filming.
Joseph 'Jeff' Bynens, 76, was swimming in the sea when he was attacked by the predator on December 14. Source: Jam Press

Woman killed by shark just days earlier

Just days before Bynens death, a mum was killed by a shark in Melaque, located west of Mexico City. María Fernanda Martínez Jiménez went into the sea with her five-year-old child when the shark bit off most of her left leg.

The 26-year-old was carried to the shore by three beachgoers, but she bled to death on the sand just minutes later. Her child was unscathed in the shark attack. The local authorities launched an investigation to determine the exact circumstances of the attack and evaluate security measures in the coastal area.

Jam Press

Love Australia's weird and wonderful environment? Get our new weekly newsletter showcasing the week’s best stories.

Banner reads 'What on Earth' with 'Subscribe to our new weekly newsletter' and a collage of images of australian natural wildlife.
Click here to sign up to our newsletter.