How 21 floating feet could help solve Melissa Caddick case

Brianne Tolj
·4-min read

A strange phenomenon in Canada could help explain how Melissa Caddick’s decomposing foot was found last month, 400km away from where she went missing.

The accused 49-year-old Sydney fraudster, who is said to have stolen up to $20 million from investors, was last seen at her luxury Dover Heights home on November 11.

On February 21, campers found her decaying foot in her Asics runnings shoes washed ashore on Bournda Beach, south of Tathra in southern NSW.

The extensive distance the foot would have travelled if she’s entered the water in Sydney has raised some eyebrows, with some senior police officers doubting such a scenario could eventuate.

However, some people are drawing comparison to the 21 disembodied feet that have washed up in Canada since 2007.

Melissa Caddick's foot inside a shoe on a beach is seen left. Ms Caddick is seen right.
Melissa Caddick's foot was found inside a shoe on a beach on the NSW south coast. Source: 7NEWS/AAP

Running shoe may have protected foot

The sheer volume of individual feet, often found inside sneakers, led to a Canadian coronial investigation into the mystery in 2017.

It ruled that the appendages belonged to people who died in accidents or by suicide and that the feet became detached during normal decomposition, Dr Matthew Orde, a forensic pathologist with the University of British Columbia, told The Sydney Morning Herald.

He said they now believe the feet were found “many, many miles” away from where people first entered the water because of the buoyancy of the running shoes.

“One of the theories is that those running shoes, by virtues of the air pockets in them, are quite buoyant,” Dr Orde said.

Forensic pathologist and Sydney University Professor Jo Duflou told the publication the footwear may have protected Ms Caddick’s feet, or it may have been taken south by a shark.

Last week, NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Mick Willing said foul play has not been ruled out, though suicide is more likely.

Bournda Beach. Source: Getty
Melissa Caddick's foot was found at Bournda Beach. Source: Getty

"Given the circumstances of the disappearance (and) the fact that she left personal belongings behind, we've always considered the possibility that she might have taken her own life," Mr Willing said.

Modelling by NSW Police marine rescue teams, taking tides and drift patterns into account, has explored the possibility that Ms Caddick entered the water in the Dover Heights area around November 12.

The modelling deemed it possible that her body could have drifted to Bournda.

New police theory about Melissa Caddick before her death

The news comes after police told The Daily Telegraph that Ms Caddick may have been alive for weeks after she disappeared from her Sydney mansion.

Superintendent Joe McNulty, Commander of the NSW Marine Command, said it was unlikely her body could have drifted to the NSW South Coast, and thought the foot had not shown signs of being in water for a long period of time.

Royal Canadian Mounted Police Constable Annie Linteau, right, speaks as a photograph of a shoe that was on one of five feet that washed up in Canada is displayed. Source: AAP
Police speak as a photograph of a shoe that was on one of five feet that washed up in Canada is displayed. Source: AAP

“Something in the water for that long, say a bit of flotsam or jetsam that washes onto the shore, has got green growth on it,” Superintendent Joe McNulty, Commander of the NSW Marine Command, told the publication.

“At first examination the shoe doesn’t appear to have been in the water for three months. The shoe needs extensive analysis to see how long it was in the water. It’s a vital clue where hopefully marine biology can provide some answers.

"[A body drifting that far has] never happened in my time in the water police."

Police continue to search for remains

Police are continuing to scour beaches on the south coast for traces of remains of Ms Caddick.

Remains have been located at three separate beaches since her foot was found.

Melissa Caddick with her husband.
The accused 49-year-old Sydney fraudster, who is said to have stolen up to $20 million from investors, was last seen at her luxury Dover Heights home on November 11. Source: AAP

People on popular Mollymook Beach discovered a chunk of stomach flesh on Friday evening and called police.

Additional remains were found at Cunjurong Point on Saturday afternoon and Warrain Beach at Culburra on Sunday morning.

Police said on Monday evening they would forensically examine the findings to determine if they belonged to the 49-year-old.

Remains found by members of the public at Tura Beach on Saturday evening have been confirmed to come from an animal.

With AAP

Readers seeking support and information about suicide prevention can contact Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636, Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Suicide Call Back Service on 1300 659 467.

Do you have a story tip? Email: newsroomau@yahoonews.com.

You can also follow us on Instagram and Twitter and download the Yahoo News app from the App Store or Google Play.