Comer investigating news-rating group

Sarah Fortinsky

13 June 2024 at 7:54 pm·2-min read

House Oversight Committee Chair James Comer (R-Ky.) announced Thursday he is launching a probe into a news-rating system that seeks to guard against misinformation by scoring news and information sites based on their reliability, trustworthiness and financial conflict of interest.

Comer said the probe will focus on “the impact of NewsGuard on protected First Amendment speech and its potential to serve as a non-transparent agent of censorship campaigns.”

In a letter to NewsGuard’s chief executive officers, veteran news executives Steven Brill and Gordon Crovitz, Comer requested documents on the company’s contracts with federal agencies and “its adherence to its own policies intended to guard against appearances of bias,” including how the company avoids conflicts of interest.

“The Committee seeks to make an independent determination about whether NewsGuard’s intervention on protected speech has been in any way sponsored by a federal, state, local, or foreign government,” Comer wrote in his letter.

“The Committee does not take issue with a business entity providing other businesses and customers with data-based analysis to protect their brands. Rather, we are concerned with the potential involvement of government entities in interfering with free expression. Truthfulness and transparency about the purpose and origin of inquiries and managing conflicts of interest that may impact the public good are also relevant,” Comer added in the letter.

NewsGuard is a web extension that rates the reliability of news sources, in what appears as a nutrition label. The scores come from a team of “expert journalists” who rate publishers on a scale of 0-100, based on “a set of apolitical criteria of journalistic practice,” according to the website.

The factors include whether the site repeatedly publishes “false or egregiously misleading content,” whether it presents the information “responsibly,” whether it has “effective practices for correcting errors,” and whether it treats opinion and news differently. Other criteria include avoiding deceptive headlines, disclosing ownership and financing and revealing possible conflicts of interest.

“We look forward to clarifying the misunderstanding by the committee about our work for the Defense Department,” Crovitz said in a statement to The Hill. “Our work for the Pentagon has been solely related to hostile disinformation efforts by Russian, Chinese and Iranian government-linked operations targeting Americans and our allies.”

Crovitz, a former publisher of The Wall Street Journal, also touted NewsGuard as “the only apolitical service” that rates news outlets, saying, “the others are either digital platforms with their secret ratings or left-wing partisan advocacy groups.”

He noted the rating system has resulted in positive and negative scores for right-leaning and left-leaning outlets.

“Under NewsGuard’s apolitical rating system, many conservative outlets outscore similar left-leaning brands: The Daily Caller outscores The Daily Beast, the Daily Wire outscores the Daily Kos, Fox News outscores MSNBC and The Wall Street Journal outscores the New York Times,” he wrote.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

HuffPost
CNN Data Reporter 'Speechless' By New Donald Trump-Joe Biden Poll: 'Holy Cow, Folks!'
Harry Enten said it could point to "a historic moment" in American politics.
HuffPost
Jon Stewart Busts 'Right-Wing Motherf**kers' Like Trump Over 1 Huge Lie
The "Daily Show" host tore into conservatives over a major hypocrisy on a key talking point.
Yahoo Finance AU
$243 cost-of-living payments hit Centrelink recipient accounts this week
As winter pushes up the energy bills, 210,000 Australians will get a $243 cost-of-living payment.
HuffPost
Ex-RNC Chair Michael Steele Calls ‘BS’ On Trump’s ‘Black Friends’ Claim
The former president’s claim gets put to the test on MSNBC.
HuffPost
Lara Trump Names Difference Between GOP And Dems, And Critics Aren’t Having It
Donald Trump's daughter-in-law, who is the co-chair of the Republican National Committee, was accused of gaslighting with her claim.
CNN
Steve Bannon won’t be spending his prison term in a ‘Club Fed’ as he had hoped, sources say
When former Donald Trump adviser Steve Bannon goes to prison, he won’t be serving time at what’s known as a “Club Fed,” the most comfortable type of facility in the federal system, as he had wanted, according to people familiar with the arrangements.
HuffPost
Anthony Fauci Memoir Recalls His Last Conversation With Donald Trump: ‘That F**ker Biden’
The then-president also reportedly made a bold prediction that didn't come true.
Sky News
South Korea fires more warning shots at North Korean soldiers crossing DMZ as landmines explode
Landmine explosions have caused multiple North Korean causalities after troops were reported to have crossed into the demilitarised zone on the border with South Korea. In a separate incident the Yonhap news agency reported that South Korea's military had fired warning shots at a group of 20 to 30 North Koreans who had breached the Military Demarcation Line. It comes as Russia's President Vladimir Putin begins a visit to Pyongyang, his first trip to North Korea in 24 years, and marks the second border violation in just two weeks.
The Independent
Ukraine-Russia war – live: Putin heads to North Korea for visit as Russian port hit in fresh drone strike
Vladimir Putin claimed Russia and North Korea have developed good relations and partnerships over the past 70 years based on equality, mutual respect and trust in a letter printed by state media ahead of his visit
HuffPost
James Carville Surprises Ari Melber With Trump-Biden Debate Prediction
The longtime Democratic strategist said he would take even money on it happening.
Bloomberg
China to Include Australia in Visa Waiver Program, Premier Li Says
(Bloomberg) -- China will include Australia in its visa waiver program, Premier Li Qiang announced after meeting with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in Canberra, in the latest sign of warming relations between the two countries.Most Read from BloombergFlesh-Eating Bacteria That Can Kill in Two Days Spreads in JapanHow the US Mopped Up a Third of Global Capital Flows Since CovidThese Are the World’s Most Expensive Cities for Expats in 2024Ukraine Bid for Global South Support Falters at Swiss Sum
NewsWire
Game-changing move for millions of Aussies
A doctor’s appointment could become cheaper for residents in one state after an Australian-first $189m budget measure.
The Daily Beast
MAGA Influencers Spread Fake SCOTUS Barricade Videos Before Trump Ruling
Several right-wing accounts on X pushed a false narrative Monday that barricades had been installed around the Supreme Court ahead of its ruling regarding former President Donald Trump’s sweeping claims of immunity from criminal prosecution.In a since-deleted post, Turning Point USA contributor and serial plagiarist Benny Johnson shared a 22-second video clip of barricades surrounding the high court.The clip began to gain traction and the same video soon showed up on several other right-wing acc
Yahoo Finance AU
Interest rate cuts: Major banks predictions ahead of RBA meeting
ANZ has broken away from the pack, with NAB, Commonwealth Bank and Westpac painting a more positive picture for Aussie borrowers.
The Independent
State Department rejects Xi’s claim that US wants China to invade Taiwan
State spokesman says ‘One China’ policy unchanged after question from The Independent
CNN
US blasts ‘aggressive’ China over South China Sea collision with Philippine ship
The United States on Monday condemned China over a collision with the Philippines in the disputed South China Sea, the latest in a series of increasingly fraught confrontations that have raised the potential of a flashpoint for global conflict in the vital waterway.
The Independent
Serena Williams gets testy when asked about Trump after being named on regular call list
‘I spoke to every president since I’ve been alive, including Ronald Reagan, I’ll have you know,’ former tennis star says
CNN
G7 leaders accuse China of ‘enabling’ Russia war on Ukraine in stark warning
China’s support for Russia is “enabling” its war in Ukraine, leaders of the world’s most advanced economies warned Friday in a hardening of tone against Beijing, threatening further sanctions against actors that materially support Moscow’s war machine.
CNN
Indian suspect in plot to kill Sikh separatist extradited to US
An Indian man suspected by the U.S. of involvement in an unsuccessful plot to kill a Sikh separatist on American soil has been extradited to the United States from the Czech Republic, according to the federal Bureau of Prisons website and a source familiar with the matter.
Australian Associated Press
Dutton preferred PM but election win remains unlikely
Opposition Leader Peter Dutton has edged out Anthony Albanese as preferred prime minister with voters marking down Labor on the economy and protecting borders.

Latest stories