Body found in southern Ontario in 2005 identified as B.C. woman using sophisticated DNA testing

Tammy Penner of Chilliwack, B.C., was 41 when she was reported missing in February 2005. Her body was found on Aug. 28 that year, in a wooded area of a rest stop near Guelph, Ont., but her identity was unknown until genetic genealogy was used to crack the case. (Ontario Provincial Police - image credit)
Tammy Penner of Chilliwack, B.C., was 41 when she was reported missing in February 2005. Her body was found on Aug. 28 that year, in a wooded area of a rest stop near Guelph, Ont., but her identity was unknown until genetic genealogy was used to crack the case. (Ontario Provincial Police - image credit)

Nearly 19 years after a woman's body was found in a wooded area at a southern Ontario picnic rest stop, police have identified her as a missing 41-year-old from Chilliwack, B.C., after turning to sophisticated DNA testing.

Ontario Provincial Police say Tammy Eileen Penner is the woman found dead at the rest area off Highway 7 between Guelph and Rockwood on Aug. 28, 2005.

Penner's body was found under a Woods-brand sleeping bag. Police say it appeared she had been dragged a short distance into the woods about a month before the remains were found. She wasn't wearing any jewelry or identification, and it's believed her clothing — a pair of black shorts, a beige tank top, white underwear and a peach-coloured bra — was purchased in the Montreal area.

Over the years, police have released sketches and other artist renderings of Penner in hopes of getting help to identify her.

OPP Det. Insp. Randy Gaynor told CBC News that police used investigative genetic genealogy to help crack the case. This April, a presumptive identification was made and used to located Penner's family members. Then, a family member's DNA was used to confirm Penner's identity.

"This is 19 years in the making and the investigative genetic genealogy that we're utilizing, it's a big advancement in policing to help us solve not only crimes, but just identifying people for their family members," Gaynor said.

Penner was reported missing to the RCMP on Feb. 7, 2005. Before disappearing, she had lived in Chilliwack and Abbotsford.

The cause of death is undetermined but is considered suspicious, Gaynor said. It appears that before her death, police said, she had a broken left cheek, nose and left eye socket, which had healed.

"We're hoping that people will recognize and name Tammy Penner as being in Ontario or even being in British Columbia and coming to Ontario with someone, and we're hoping that anyone that has information will come forward with any information they have that will assist us in determining her cause of death," Gaynor said.

A memorial exists at the rest stop where Tammy Penner's body was found near Guelph, Ont., in 2005. Local community members, including the Rockwood Knights of Columbus, created it and maintained it to remember the woman for years before anyone knew who she was.
A memorial exists at the rest stop where Tammy Penner's body was found near Guelph, Ont., in 2005. Local community members, including the Rockwood Knights of Columbus, created it and maintained it to remember the woman for years before anyone knew who she was.

A memorial at the rest stop where Penner's body was found near Guelph in 2005. Local community members, including the Rockwood Knights of Columbus, created and maintained it to remember the woman for years before anyone knew her identity. (Ontario Provincial Police)

For years, a memorial has been set up at the rest area where Penner's body was found.

Gaynor said he has been in contact with Penner's family and they were appreciative of what people have done to remember someone whose identity wasn't known.

"The memorial like that was very touching for them," he said.

Anyone with information about Penner is asked to contact OPP or Crime Stoppers.