Spruce Lake Industrial Park expansion slowed down, Saint John creates task force

The Spruce Lake Industrial Park expansion is a city and province-led plan to make hundreds of hectares in the area ready for development to attract large businesses operations to the city.  (Roger Cosman/CBC  - image credit)
The Spruce Lake Industrial Park expansion is a city and province-led plan to make hundreds of hectares in the area ready for development to attract large businesses operations to the city. (Roger Cosman/CBC - image credit)

Saint John has hit the brakes on plans to expand the Spruce Lake Industrial Park and will create a task force to encourage further discussion of the controversial project.

At a meeting Tuesday night, council postponed a public hearing and a council vote on the expansion proposal, originally set for Nov 12. A new date was not set.

Residents opposed to the project near their community attended the council meeting and welcomed the promise of further discussion with the city.

"I'm pleased with the result that we've postponed the actual vote on whether it's going to be rezoned," said Ken McCavour, who lives in Lorneville in the southwest part of Saint John.

The move comes a week after a lengthy planning advisory committee meeting where Lorneville residents made at times  emotional arguments against the project.

The planning committee said "more conversation" about the project was needed and voted to make no recommendation to council.

"Now we have to wait and see whether we can do something, work out some deal with the city that everybody's happy with," McCavour said.

Lorneville resident Ken McCavour says he lives close to the development area. He is pleased with the resolution of a task force and hopes it will result in a larger buffer zone.
Lorneville resident Ken McCavour says he lives close to the development area. He is pleased with the resolution of a task force and hopes it will result in a larger buffer zone.

Lorneville resident Ken McCavour, who lives close to the development area, was pleased with council's decision to create task force. (Nipun Tiwari/CBC)

The Spruce Lake Industrial Park expansion is a city and province-led endeavour to redesignate hundreds of hectares in the area for heavy industrial development to attract large business operations to Saint John.

Residents first became aware of the plans in July. In a month-long consultation period since then, the city and province received hundreds of letters from residents and a petition opposed to the plans.

The pushback led the city to modify the proposal sent to the planning advisory committee. The changes would increase a buffer zone at the site and create a benefits program where land sales from the proposal would help fund Lorneville community projects.

The changes did not quell residents' concerns.

Community push back to the proposal resulted in the city bringing the item to last weeks Planning Advisory Committee with some changes including a buffer zone increased from 30 meters to 150 meters and a community benefits program.
Community push back to the proposal resulted in the city bringing the item to last weeks Planning Advisory Committee with some changes including a buffer zone increased from 30 meters to 150 meters and a community benefits program.

Community opposition to the proposal has already led to some changes in the plan, including a larger buffer zone and a community benefits program. (City of Saint John)

Now a task force to be made up of city staff and Lorneville community leaders will further discuss the proposal.

Staff are to come back to council with a report that will include recommendations and findings from the  discussions.

Council pleased with direction 

Mayor Donna Reardon and councillors expressed support for slowing things down to sort out problems.

"I love it.," Reardon said. "It aligns us with the decision of [planning advisory committee], the claim that there is more work to be done between the two parties — I agree.

"I think that demonstrates that council and staff have heard the residents of Lorneville. If we want to move forward, we want to move forward together. … We'll create a task force. We'll have residents on it, we'll have staff on it, figure out what those sticking points are and what the path forward is."

Lorneville resident, Dawn Alexander, says she is happy with the public hearing date being postponed and hopes to continue communicating with the city about the community's concerns.
Lorneville resident, Dawn Alexander, says she is happy with the public hearing date being postponed and hopes to continue communicating with the city about the community's concerns.

Lorneville resident Dawn Alexander says hopes a larger buffer zone will be one result of the task force discussions. (Nipun Tiwari/CBC)

Coun. Gary Sullivan praised city staff for creating a recommendation quickly.

"I think there's definitely a path forward in the conversation that can be had, so I'm looking forward to seeing the results," he said.

Reardon said a public hearing and vote on the project likely won't happen until the new year.

Resident glad of chance to speak up

Another Lorneville resident, Dawn Alexander, also feels the move is the right decision.

"We hope to talk more with the councillors and tell them our concerns that heavy industry should not be by residential property lines and should not be close to a community," Alexander said.

"An industrial park is made to be away from community and to push the industrial park close to us, it's a conflict of land use."

McCavour, who lives near the development area, hopes one outcome of the planned discussion is an increased buffer zone.

"It needs to be larger . … I live on the opposite side of where the construction would actually be. It would be within, like,  100 metres of where I am. And it's got to be farther."