A widowed mother of five young girls fell victim to every woman's worst nightmare when two masked men broke into her home and raped her.
They threatened her daughters, who were all asleep in the house, if she made a sound.
The Ballarat mother waited 30 years to see one of her attackers brought to justice, and on Tuesday Victoria's top court upheld the prison sentence he's now serving.
Brett Braddock, then 26, lived in the same neighbourhood as the woman in 1990. He was questioned at the time when police canvassed the neighbourhood.
But it wasn't until he was approached by cold case investigators for a DNA sample in 2019 that he was caught.
Braddock was jailed in August last year for 12 years and two months over the attack, described by Justice Philip Priest as horrifying and despicable.
But his lawyer Sharon Lacy challenged the sentence in a Court of Appeal hearing on Tuesday, saying both it and the nine-year non-parole period were manifestly excessive.
The sentencing judge had double punished him, she argued, saying he had been sentenced on a burglary charge as well as it being an aggravating feature of the rape that it occurred in the woman's own home.
She also said the judge had not focused enough on mitigating features, including his rehabilitation had been "significantly achieved" and he was a low risk of sexual re-offending.
Ms Lacy began the hearing by dropping two grounds of appeal, a move described as sensible by Justice Priest who added one of them had "absolutely no legs whatsoever".
Braddock was convicted of two counts of aggravated rape - one over his own rape of the woman and the other for holding her down while the co-accused, who has never been identified, raped her twice.
Justice Priest said the sentence for the second rape charge, rather than being manifestly excessive, might have been "far too modest".
He wouldn't have been surprised had it received the same or more jail time.
Prosecutor Elizabeth Ruddle QC said nothing about Braddock's sentence could be said to be manifestly excessive.
"It takes of bit of imagination to think of a worse example of this kind of offence," she said.
Quoting the case's previous prosecutor, Robyn Harper, the sentencing judge Patricia Riddell said the attack was every woman's worst nightmare.
"No matter how long ago, it is offending which horrifies and shocks the community. It offends our sense of safety and the sanctity of our homes," she said.