Advertisement

Court decides sperm donor is legal father of girl and can stop her move overseas

A sperm donor has been deemed by the High Court as the legal father of his child because he was involved in her life.

The case has its beginnings in late 2006, when Robert Masson and Susan Parsons (their court pseudonyms) agreed to have a child through artificial insemination.

Mr Masson agreed on the understanding he would parent, provide financial support and financial care.

A NSW sperm donor fathered a child with a lesbian friend through artificial insemination.
A NSW man has been caught up in a legal battle after donating his sperm to a lesbian woman to father a child through artificial insemination. Source: AAP, file

He is named as the girl's father on her birth certificate and was actively involved in the girl and her younger sister's life, with both calling him "Daddy".

Issues arose when the mother and her female partner wanted to move to New Zealand with the girls.

Mr Masson stopped them through the Family Court as he was found to be a parent, but on appeal NSW state laws were used to rule him as purely a sperm donor.

The girl's mother and her partner argued NSW law clearly spelled out rules for fertilisation procedures with respect to same-sex couples.

The NSW High Court, pictured, deemed a sperm donor the legal father of his child because he was involved in her life.
The sperm donor has been deemed by the High Court as the legal father of his child because he was involved in her life financially and emotionally. Source: AAP, file

However, Solicitor General Stephen Donaghue QC successfully argued in the High Court in April that the commonwealth definition should be used.

"State law is just not relevant," he told the court.

The argument was put that under Commonwealth law Mr Masson is considered a parent, as he is the biological father and is involved in the child's life.

A majority of the High Court agreed, saying in a judgment on Wednesday no reason had been shown to doubt the initial court conclusion that Mr Masson was a parent of the child.

The High Court said the women should consult with Mr Masson about parenting decisions including the New Zealand move.

Do you have a story tip? Email: newsroomau@yahoonews.com.

You can also follow us on Facebook, download the Yahoo News app from iTunes or Google Play and stay up to date with the latest news with Yahoo’s daily newsletter. Sign up here.