MS sufferer wants dignified death

TIFFANY FOX, The West Australian Updated February 3, 2010, 2:35 am
Former nurse Jill has stopped taking the medication which would prolong her life.

WA News / Michael Wilson © Former nurse Jill has stopped taking the medication which would prolong her life.

Unable to walk and stripped of her independence after living with multiple sclerosis for more than 20 years, former nurse Jill feels life has become an unbearable prison.

Less than five months after right-to-die campaigner Christian Rossiter died following a landmark Supreme Court decision which allowed his nursing home to comply with his wish to starve to death, the State Government's stance against euthanasia is set to be challenged again after the former registered nurse yesterday stopped taking medication which will prolong her life and pleaded to be allowed to die with dignity.

Jill, who did not want her last name published, said her quality of life was non-existent and she was prepared to die a "slow and ugly" death rather than "suffer the indignity" of having the debilitating condition rule its course.

Jill said that since being diagnosed with the neurological condition in 1988 she had lost the ability to walk and found it difficult to talk, swallow and eat.

Her vision had deteriorated until she could no longer watch television or read. She had lost control of her bodily functions and she had to relinquish the motorised scooter which was her only means of leaving her unit.

Jill said while she knew she could legally refuse to take medication or food, she previously had not wanted to put her family through the pain of seeing her slowly die. But she said she no longer wanted to endure the "degradation" of her worsening condition and without the option of legal voluntary euthanasia, she said she had been stripped of her freedom to choose to die legally and with dignity.

A side effect of multiple sclerosis caused fluid to build up in her body. Without her medication, Jill said the fluid would cause her body to swell and, over the course of weeks or months, would slowly "drown" her internal organs and most likely lead to organ failure.

"I think it will take time. I think it could be long and ugly but I can't suffer any more indignity than I already have," she said. "The humiliation of knowing an animal is given more compassion than a human being is beyond words."

The grandmother had previously attempted suicide and tried to buy illegal drugs to take an overdose but said she did want not to die in a "covert fashion". In a petition that was read to Parliament in 2008, Jill begged for legislation that would allow her children to be by her side at her death without fear of prosecution.

She realised laws would not be changed in time to affect her situation but hoped her case, like Mr Rossiter's, would reignite public debate over voluntary euthanasia.

Jill's lawyer, John Hammond, said the 61-year-old's plight was "heartbreaking" and highlighted the need for a clear stance on legal voluntary euthanasia.

Greens MP Robin Chapple, whose euthanasia Bill is expected to be debated when Parliament resumes, said he sympathised with Jill's plight but was unable to condone her actions.


Follow thewest.com.au on Twitter
Show:
Oldest First
Newest First
Top Rated
Most Replies
1 - 10 of 12

12 Comments

  1. 05:45am Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

    It will never cease to amaze and sadden me,why when our beloved pets no longer have quality of life,we are advised to have them euthanased.yet,our own misery,we are forced to continue living.As a sister,who watched a loved one perish over many years,who watched her torment,pain,sadness...I am...

    Reply
    1. 08:02am Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

      CHRISTIAN SENSIBILITIES dictate peoples fate along with a dash of doo gooding Doctoring as well. If they want out let them go!

      Reply
      1. 08:35am Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

        I feel sorry for this woman, but I wonder if she's a bit of a publicity seeker? I know if I wanted to die I would not try and draw attention to it, but just do it (i.e. a bottle of sleeping tablets).

        Reply
        1. Guy08:41am Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

          I think she is trying to get the publicity to further the cause of euthanasia and bring the suffering of people like herself into the front of peoples minds. Shirl is right, if your dog has untreatable cancer and is in pain, you get it gently put to sleep but if its your mum or dad or yourself, you...

          Reply
          1. astro08:57am Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

            What a horrible thing to deal with, this poor lady. I think if she's happy to go then the law should let her - like others have said if your pets can why can't we.

            Reply
            1. Lager09:57am Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

              It's her life, an no-one else should dictate this decision for her. Hopefully she can achieve her wish on her terms without interference from any self-righteous do-gooders

              Reply
              1. 12:27pm Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

                Apparently only animals are allowed to die with dignity. Humans have to suffer till the very end to ease doo- gooders conscience. Its very sad we dont have control over our own lives.

                Reply
                1. Tony Lush01:04pm Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

                  Thankyou Jill for the Courage to Make a stand publically and in the courts , so those of us to follow might just have an easier time when their time comes

                  Reply
                  1. Sistermoon01:13pm Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

                    We have the right to live, give us the right to die.......

                    Reply
                    1. David G03:38pm Wednesday 03rd February 2010 WSTReport Abuse

                      God Bless you Jill. Come guys, she has her rights too. Respect that.

                      Reply
                      1 - 10 of 12

                      Post a comment

                      Do you have a Yahoo! ID? Sign in | Sign up

                      Perth

                      Currently

                      27.5°

                      Today's forecast: Hazy

                      19° - 30°

                      West Rewards

                      West Rewards

                      My Resources

                      The West News Preferences

                      Close

                      Select your state to see news for your area.